Anthony is the Director of Campus Ministry at Notre Dame College in Cleveland, Ohio. He was on staff at St. Noel Parish in Willoughby Hills, OH from 1995 to 2008 where he headed up the junior high and high school ministry program and directed the local furniture bank. Previously he worked at the West Side Catholic Center, a drop-in center in Cleveland, and taught religion at Trinity High School in Garfield Heights, Ohio. He graduated from Borromeo College of Ohio in 1986 with a bachelor of arts in philosophy and earned his master's degree in theology from St. Mary Seminary and Graduate School of Theology in Cleveland. Anthony and his wife, Laura, have one son, Dominic.